Is St. Louis Cardinals super utility man Brendan Donovan overrated, or is the front office playing 4D chess? Bernie Miklasz dives deep into the metrics and trade rumors to separate the marketing hype from the reality of Donovan's value on the field.

","highlights","status","PUBLISHED","featuredImage","/img/cardinals/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-12-19-25-544x306.jpg","seo",{"_375":868,"_869":870,"_871":872,"_888":889,"_890":865},"The Bernie Show: Donovan's Actual Trade Value","excerpt","Are the St. Louis Cardinals going to trade Brendan Donovan soon, and if they do, what will they receive in return?","keyInfo",[873,877,881,885],{"_38":874,"_34":875,"_36":876},"Major League Baseball","league","major-league-baseball",{"_38":878,"_34":879,"_36":880},"St Louis Cardinals","team","st-louis-cardinals",{"_38":882,"_34":883,"_36":884},"Brendan Donovan","player","brendan-donovan",{"_38":886,"_34":883,"_36":887},"Chaim Bloom","chaim-bloom","contentLength",83,"defaultImage","pageViews","commentCount","0","categoryFilter",{"_896":897,"_898":899},"property","specs.tag","values",[900],"stl-sports-central","slugUrl","2025/12/19/the-bernie-show-12-19-25","lock",{"_905":53,"_906":-5,"_907":-5,"_908":-5},"isLocked","userName","userId","date","categoryId","userReactions",[],"reactionSummary",[],"feedPageHeading","feedPageHeadingLineTwo","feedPageTitle","feedPageDescription","feedPageLogo","hideFeedForum","prohibitComments","prohibitReactions","prohibitReactionsInComments","hideFeaturedImage","advancedOptions","feedBorderOverrideColor","feedBlurb","tag",[929,931,933,935,937,939,941,942,943,944,945],{"_7":927,"_733":930},"sports",{"_7":927,"_733":932},"missouri-sports",{"_7":927,"_733":934},"saint-louis-sports",{"_7":927,"_733":936},"saint-louis",{"_7":927,"_733":938},"st-louis",{"_7":927,"_733":940},"st-louis-sports",{"_7":927,"_733":900},{"_7":875,"_733":876},{"_7":879,"_733":880},{"_7":883,"_733":884},{"_7":883,"_733":887},"isPremium","isWarning","isTertiary","hasEmbed","types",[952],"video","videoInfo",{"_955":956},"url","https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zNBFgy0s01Y","podcastInfo",{"_955":18},"relatedArticles",{"_15":961,"_962":963},[],"filters",[964],{"_896":897,"_898":965},[900],"thumbnail","/img/cardinals/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-12-19-25-thumbnail.jpg","publishedOn","2025-12-19T21:26:00.000Z","featuredImageUrl","cacheKey","shstl_the-bernie-show-12-19-25","cachedOn","2026-03-17T05:33:51.169Z","contentBlocks",[977,983,986,988,990],{"_34":978,"_15":979,"_982":18},"ad",{"_34":82,"_36":128,"_38":128,"_39":18,"_41":18,"_42":23,"_43":129,"_44":18,"_46":18,"_47":18,"_48":18,"_50":980,"_52":53,"_54":53,"_55":53,"_56":53,"_57":981},[],{"_59":18,"_60":18,"_61":18,"_62":18,"_63":18,"_64":18,"_65":18,"_66":18,"_68":18,"_69":18},"html",{"_34":984,"_982":985},"text","

",{"_34":984,"_982":987},"

",{"_34":984,"_982":989},"

",{"_34":984,"_982":989},"metaSettings",{"_375":376,"_377":378,"_147":379,"_380":376,"_381":382,"_383":382,"_384":382,"_385":382,"_386":993,"_395":396,"_397":18,"_398":382,"_399":382,"_400":382,"_401":402},{"_388":389,"_390":391,"_392":393,"_394":333},"sidebarSections",[996,1090,1172],{"_162":997,"_1000":1001,"_1002":1003,"_1004":1003,"_962":1005},{"_375":998,"_377":18,"_999":18},"Bernie Miklasz Written Content","image","articles",[],"desktopLayoutStyle","default","mobileLayoutStyle",[1006],{"_34":927,"_36":1007,"_1008":217,"_15":1009,"_1022":1023,"_898":1024,"_1088":45,"_950":1089},"bernie-miklasz","count",{"_36":1007,"_38":1010,"_856":-5,"_34":927,"_140":1011,"_1020":1021},"bernie miklasz",{"_142":1012,"_143":1013,"_147":-5,"_148":1015,"_150":-5,"_151":-5,"_152":1016},"973aec08-a44b-4277-b40c-693f768934cd",{"_36":-5,"_7":1014,"_146":-5},"Specification",[],{"_154":1017,"_156":1018,"_158":1018,"_159":1019},"2025-03-23T14:57:49.169Z","9c11c01e-d312-4b5a-a115-bf834a35f1e0","2025-03-23T14:57:49.171Z","contentTypes",[842],"load","preload",[1025,1046,1060,1074],{"_999":1026,"_844":1027,"_901":1028,"_927":1010,"_908":1029,"_968":1030,"_852":1031,"_858":1034,"_375":1035,"_397":1036,"_869":1036,"_946":53,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1037":190,"_892":893,"_36":1038,"_422":842,"_1039":53,"_910":1040,"_912":1041,"_920":53,"_921":53,"_922":53,"_924":1042,"_846":1038,"_953":1043,"_1044":18,"_1045":-5,"_926":-5},"/img/bernie/bernie-central-rev-544x306.jpg","bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-3-16-26","/2026/03/16/bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-3-16-26","2026-03-16T22:22:14.447Z","2026-03-16T22:40:00.000Z",{"_38":336,"_36":1032,"_856":1033},"berniemiklasz","/avatars/berniemiklasz.jpg",[],"REDBIRD REVIEW: Cards Satisfying Spring Training Progress Report","The Cardinals haven’t had this many talented, capable arms in spring training for a long time. ","viewCount","142acf50-654e-4210-b855-a46971150d85","isLiveFile",[],[],{},{"_955":-5},"externalUrl","subHeadings",{"_999":1026,"_844":1047,"_901":1048,"_927":1010,"_908":1049,"_968":1050,"_852":1051,"_858":1052,"_375":1053,"_397":1054,"_869":1054,"_946":53,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1037":190,"_892":893,"_36":1055,"_422":842,"_1039":53,"_910":1056,"_912":1057,"_920":53,"_921":53,"_922":53,"_924":1058,"_846":1055,"_953":1059,"_1044":18,"_1045":-5,"_926":-5},"bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-3-13-26","/2026/03/13/bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-3-13-26","2026-03-13T22:35:35.492Z","2026-03-13T22:50:00.000Z",{"_38":336,"_36":1032,"_856":1033},[],"REDBIRD REVIEW: Pujols and Molina Sharpening Skills in WBC","Pujols and Molina want to manage in Major League Baseball, and the WBC stage should raise awareness and put them in line for an opportunity. ","2606079b-ca79-4a5c-92e8-2cd97bc3e726",[],[],{},{"_955":-5},{"_999":1026,"_844":1061,"_901":1062,"_927":1010,"_908":1063,"_968":1064,"_852":1065,"_858":1066,"_375":1067,"_397":1068,"_869":1068,"_946":53,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1037":190,"_892":190,"_36":1069,"_422":842,"_1039":53,"_910":1070,"_912":1071,"_920":53,"_921":53,"_922":53,"_924":1072,"_846":1069,"_953":1073,"_1044":18,"_1045":-5,"_926":-5},"bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-3-12-26","/2026/03/12/bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-3-12-26","2026-03-12T22:12:51.030Z","2026-03-12T22:31:00.000Z",{"_38":336,"_36":1032,"_856":1033},[],"REDBIRD REVIEW: Wetherholt Projections and Past No. 3 MLB Prospects","Call me Fredibird but I sincerely believe Wetherholt will have a strong rookie season for the Cardinals.","f7e4f1d5-f29e-492e-bf82-54c64c7cb6c4",[],[],{},{"_955":-5},{"_999":1026,"_844":1075,"_901":1076,"_927":1010,"_908":1077,"_968":1078,"_852":1079,"_858":1080,"_375":1081,"_397":1082,"_869":1082,"_946":53,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1037":190,"_892":190,"_36":1083,"_422":842,"_1039":53,"_910":1084,"_912":1085,"_920":53,"_921":53,"_922":53,"_924":1086,"_846":1083,"_953":1087,"_1044":18,"_1045":-5,"_926":-5},"bernie-miklasz-bernie-bits-3-11-26","/2026/03/11/bernie-miklasz-bernie-bits-3-11-26","2026-03-11T22:53:52.552Z","2026-03-11T23:11:00.000Z",{"_38":336,"_36":1032,"_856":1033},[],"Bernie Bits: New Generation of Redbirds Just 15 Days Away","For those of you who believe Oli Marmol will be taking orders from Chaim Bloom on lineup decisions, the leadoff spot will be our evidence. ","07833933-8966-4f85-8a51-3cc84a9b3a1e",[],[],{},{"_955":-5},"skip",[842],{"_162":1091,"_1000":1092,"_1002":1003,"_1004":1003,"_962":1093},{"_375":314,"_377":18,"_999":18},[],[1094],{"_34":927,"_36":1095,"_1008":217,"_15":1096,"_1022":1023,"_898":1107,"_1088":45,"_950":1171},"gambling-fantasy",{"_856":-5,"_34":927,"_36":1095,"_38":1097,"_1098":53,"_140":1099,"_1020":1106},"gambling fantasy ","isHidden",{"_142":1100,"_143":1101,"_147":-5,"_148":1102,"_150":-5,"_151":-5,"_152":1103},"3ce1eb25-10fd-4293-bffe-ac02c4d2ba50",{"_36":-5,"_7":1014,"_146":-5},[],{"_154":1104,"_156":157,"_158":157,"_159":1105},"2025-02-06T16:09:52.564Z","2025-02-06T16:09:54.032Z",[842],[1108,1126,1141,1156],{"_999":1109,"_844":1110,"_901":1111,"_927":1097,"_908":1112,"_968":1113,"_852":1114,"_858":1118,"_375":1119,"_397":1120,"_869":1120,"_946":53,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1037":190,"_892":893,"_36":1121,"_422":842,"_1039":53,"_910":1122,"_912":1123,"_920":53,"_921":53,"_922":53,"_924":1124,"_846":1121,"_953":1125,"_1044":18,"_1045":-5,"_926":-5},"/img/random/slu-vs-dayton-544x306.jpg","slu-billikens-dayton-flyers-march-14-2026","/2026/03/13/slu-billikens-dayton-flyers-march-14-2026","2026-03-14T01:56:07.727Z","2026-03-14T02:04:22.743Z",{"_38":1115,"_36":1116,"_856":1117},"Eric Sontag","esontag","/avatars/esontag.jpg",[],"SLU vs Dayton Betting Preview: Billikens, Flyers Play Rubber Match","Saint Louis and Dayton meet for the third time this season in the Atlantic 10 semifinals Saturday, with a trip to the conference title game on the line.","e24821e4-a0ce-49e5-af38-9b71c872de54",[],[],{},{"_955":-5},{"_999":1127,"_844":1128,"_901":1129,"_927":1097,"_908":1130,"_968":1131,"_852":1132,"_858":1133,"_375":1134,"_397":1135,"_869":1135,"_946":53,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1037":190,"_892":893,"_36":1136,"_422":842,"_1039":53,"_910":1137,"_912":1138,"_920":53,"_921":53,"_922":53,"_924":1139,"_846":1136,"_953":1140,"_1044":18,"_1045":-5,"_926":-5},"/img/random/slu-vs-george-washington-544x306.jpg","slu-billikens-george-washington-revolutionaries-march-13-2026","/2026/03/12/slu-billikens-george-washington-revolutionaries-march-13-2026","2026-03-13T03:11:24.157Z","2026-03-13T03:23:34.123Z",{"_38":1115,"_36":1116,"_856":1117},[],"SLU vs George Washington Betting Preview: Can Billikens Right The Ship?","Top-seed Saint Louis faces George Washington in the Atlantic 10 quarterfinals Friday morning. The Billikens look to avoid an upset and move one step closer to the A10 title.","a4a39c84-577c-4774-a372-ae83c4be1b20",[],[],{},{"_955":-5},{"_999":1142,"_844":1143,"_901":1144,"_927":1097,"_908":1145,"_968":1146,"_852":1147,"_858":1148,"_375":1149,"_397":1150,"_869":1150,"_946":53,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1037":190,"_892":893,"_36":1151,"_422":842,"_1039":53,"_910":1152,"_912":1153,"_920":53,"_921":53,"_922":53,"_924":1154,"_846":1151,"_953":1155,"_1044":18,"_1045":-5,"_926":-5},"/img/random/mizzou-vs-kentucky-544x306.jpg","mizzou-tigers-kentucky-wildcats-march-12-2026","/2026/03/12/mizzou-tigers-kentucky-wildcats-march-12-2026","2026-03-12T05:34:47.147Z","2026-03-12T05:47:43.476Z",{"_38":1115,"_36":1116,"_856":1117},[],"Mizzou vs Kentucky Betting Preview: Tigers Look To Beat Cats Again","Missouri faces Kentucky in the SEC Tournament second round Thursday in Nashville. The winner advances to face top-seeded Florida in the quarterfinals.","5e256c07-6099-413c-b77b-5fc3def8a255",[],[],{},{"_955":-5},{"_999":1157,"_844":1158,"_901":1159,"_927":1097,"_908":1160,"_968":1161,"_852":1162,"_858":1163,"_375":1164,"_397":1165,"_869":1165,"_946":53,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1037":190,"_892":893,"_36":1166,"_422":842,"_1039":53,"_910":1167,"_912":1168,"_920":53,"_921":53,"_922":53,"_924":1169,"_846":1166,"_953":1170,"_1044":18,"_1045":-5,"_926":-5},"/img/random/blues-vs-anaheim-544x306.jpg","st-louis-blues-anaheim-ducks-march-8-2026","/2026/03/08/st-louis-blues-anaheim-ducks-march-8-2026","2026-03-08T19:03:20.731Z","2026-03-08T19:09:12.369Z",{"_38":1115,"_36":1116,"_856":1117},[],"Blues vs Ducks Betting Preview: Streaking Blues Head To Anaheim","The St. Louis Blues visit the Anaheim Ducks on Sunday night. St. Louis enters on a three-game winning streak while Anaheim holds the top spot in the Pacific Division.","c9111922-e5d6-41b6-878b-d0057cf636db",[],[],{},{"_955":-5},[842],{"_162":1173,"_1000":1174,"_1002":1003,"_1004":1003,"_962":1175},{"_375":878,"_377":18,"_999":18},[],[1176],{"_34":879,"_36":880,"_1088":190,"_1008":217,"_15":1177,"_1022":1023,"_898":1186,"_950":1254},{"_856":-5,"_34":879,"_36":880,"_38":878,"_1098":53,"_140":1178,"_1020":1185},{"_142":1179,"_143":1180,"_147":-5,"_148":1181,"_150":-5,"_151":-5,"_152":1182},"4c4a795a-2dd7-46d4-926b-9a1a3c87ac55",{"_36":-5,"_7":1014,"_146":-5},[],{"_154":1183,"_156":157,"_158":157,"_159":1184},"2025-01-24T15:00:01.364Z","2025-01-24T15:00:02.715Z",[842],[1187,1203,1220,1237],{"_999":1188,"_844":1189,"_901":1190,"_927":376,"_908":1191,"_968":1192,"_852":1193,"_858":1194,"_375":1195,"_397":1196,"_869":1196,"_946":53,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1037":190,"_892":893,"_36":1197,"_422":842,"_1039":53,"_910":1198,"_912":1199,"_920":53,"_921":53,"_922":53,"_924":1200,"_846":1197,"_953":1201,"_1044":18,"_1045":-5,"_926":-5},"/img/cardinals/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-3-13-26-544x306.jpg","the-bernie-show-3-13-26","/2026/03/13/the-bernie-show-3-13-26","2026-03-13T19:09:53.022Z","2026-03-13T19:13:00.000Z",{"_38":854,"_36":855,"_856":857},[],"The Bernie Show: Gorman Needs to Earn Trust","Bernie takes a hard look at Gorman’s revamped plate approach, improved spring training discipline, and whether any of it can actually hold up once the games start to count.","619c8189-c1ad-4168-838c-1c7151f0907b",[],[],{},{"_955":1202},"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=trNVSKE0d2Q",{"_999":1204,"_844":1205,"_901":1206,"_927":376,"_908":1207,"_968":1208,"_852":1209,"_858":1210,"_375":1211,"_397":1212,"_869":1212,"_946":53,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1037":190,"_892":893,"_950":1213,"_36":1214,"_422":842,"_1039":53,"_910":1215,"_912":1216,"_920":53,"_921":53,"_922":53,"_924":1217,"_846":1214,"_953":1218,"_1044":18,"_1045":-5,"_926":-5},"/img/cardinals/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-3-12-26-544x306.jpg","the-bernie-show-3-12-26","/2026/03/12/the-bernie-show-3-12-26","2026-03-12T19:16:58.505Z","2026-03-12T19:21:00.000Z",{"_38":854,"_36":855,"_856":857},[],"The Bernie Show: Signs of Progress Lacking for Walker","Jordan Walker still has the talent, but the warning signs are getting louder for the 23-year-old Cardinal.",[952],"c379ab0b-ae36-4aec-86a8-fddfbe365bf5",[],[],{},{"_955":1219},"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZA1bVZ5KoI",{"_999":1221,"_844":1222,"_901":1223,"_927":376,"_908":1224,"_968":1225,"_852":1226,"_858":1227,"_375":1228,"_397":1229,"_869":1229,"_946":53,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1037":190,"_892":893,"_950":1230,"_36":1231,"_422":842,"_1039":53,"_910":1232,"_912":1233,"_920":53,"_921":53,"_922":53,"_924":1234,"_846":1231,"_953":1235,"_1044":18,"_1045":-5,"_926":-5},"/img/cardinals/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-3-11-26-544x306.jpg","the-bernie-show-3-11-26","/2026/03/11/the-bernie-show-3-11-26","2026-03-11T20:15:35.887Z","2026-03-11T20:18:00.000Z",{"_38":854,"_36":855,"_856":857},[],"The Bernie Show: Velazquez Upside","Bernie Miklasz breaks down why Nelson Velázquez is forcing his way into the conversation for the Cardinals outfield.",[952],"92d599e5-9693-400a-8c20-fa8e763eddaa",[],[],{},{"_955":1236},"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M6ElPJcdeHs",{"_999":1238,"_844":1239,"_901":1240,"_927":376,"_908":1241,"_968":1242,"_852":1243,"_858":1244,"_375":1245,"_397":1246,"_869":1246,"_946":53,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1037":190,"_892":893,"_950":1247,"_36":1248,"_422":842,"_1039":53,"_910":1249,"_912":1250,"_920":53,"_921":53,"_922":53,"_924":1251,"_846":1248,"_953":1252,"_1044":18,"_1045":-5,"_926":-5},"/img/cardinals/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-3-10-26-544x306.jpg","the-bernie-show-3-10-26","/2026/03/10/the-bernie-show-3-10-26","2026-03-10T19:18:10.264Z","2026-03-10T19:21:00.000Z",{"_38":854,"_36":855,"_856":857},[],"The Bernie Show: Cards Catcher Conundrum","If Iván Herrera is one of the Cardinals best bats, why are they still putting extra wear on him behind the plate?",[952],"d8517b99-e9d4-44ca-a36c-ef98da776b7b",[],[],{},{"_955":1253},"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1UNmV63hLfg",[842],"playerData","actionData","errors"]

The Bernie Show: Donovan's Actual Trade Value

REDBIRD REVIEW: Cards Satisfying Spring Training Progress Report

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 16, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Pujols and Molina Sharpening Skills in WBC

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 13, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Wetherholt Projections and Past No. 3 MLB Prospects

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 12, 2026

Bernie Bits: New Generation of Redbirds Just 15 Days Away

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 11, 2026

SLU vs Dayton Betting Preview: Billikens, Flyers Play Rubber Match

By Eric Sontag

Mar 13, 2026

SLU vs George Washington Betting Preview: Can Billikens Right The Ship?

By Eric Sontag

Mar 12, 2026

Mizzou vs Kentucky Betting Preview: Tigers Look To Beat Cats Again

By Eric Sontag

Mar 12, 2026

Blues vs Ducks Betting Preview: Streaking Blues Head To Anaheim

By Eric Sontag

Mar 8, 2026

The Bernie Show: Gorman Needs to Earn Trust

By HUB STAFF

Mar 13, 2026

The Bernie Show: Signs of Progress Lacking for Walker

By HUB STAFF

Mar 12, 2026

The Bernie Show: Velazquez Upside

By HUB STAFF

Mar 11, 2026

The Bernie Show: Cards Catcher Conundrum

By HUB STAFF

Mar 10, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Cards Satisfying Spring Training Progress Report

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 16, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Pujols and Molina Sharpening Skills in WBC

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 13, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Wetherholt Projections and Past No. 3 MLB Prospects

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 12, 2026

Bernie Bits: New Generation of Redbirds Just 15 Days Away

By Bernie Miklasz

Mar 11, 2026

SLU vs Dayton Betting Preview: Billikens, Flyers Play Rubber Match

By Eric Sontag

Mar 13, 2026

SLU vs George Washington Betting Preview: Can Billikens Right The Ship?

By Eric Sontag

Mar 12, 2026

Mizzou vs Kentucky Betting Preview: Tigers Look To Beat Cats Again

By Eric Sontag

Mar 12, 2026

Blues vs Ducks Betting Preview: Streaking Blues Head To Anaheim

By Eric Sontag

Mar 8, 2026

The Bernie Show: Gorman Needs to Earn Trust

By HUB STAFF

Mar 13, 2026

The Bernie Show: Signs of Progress Lacking for Walker

By HUB STAFF

Mar 12, 2026

The Bernie Show: Velazquez Upside

By HUB STAFF

Mar 11, 2026

The Bernie Show: Cards Catcher Conundrum

By HUB STAFF

Mar 10, 2026