Bernie Miklasz takes a hard look at Lars Nootbaar’s struggles in 2025. Despite impressive Statcast numbers, his real-world production is collapsing, and it’s costing the Cardinals games. Bernie dives deep into Nootbaar’s alarming stats, rising strikeouts, and declining value at the top of the order. Is it time for the Cardinals to move on? Could Brendan Donovan or J.J. Wetherholt be better options?

","highlights","status","PUBLISHED","featuredImage","/img/random/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-6-13-25-544x306.jpg","seo",{"_370":891,"_892":893,"_894":895,"_917":918,"_919":888},"The Bernie Show: New Table Setter","excerpt","Bernie Miklasz takes a hard look at Lars Nootbaar’s struggles in 2025. ","keyInfo",[896,900,904,908,911,914],{"_38":897,"_34":898,"_36":899},"Major League Baseball","league","major-league-baseball",{"_38":901,"_34":902,"_36":903},"St Louis Cardinals","team","st-louis-cardinals",{"_38":905,"_34":906,"_36":907},"Lars Nootbaar","player","lars-nootbaar",{"_38":909,"_34":906,"_36":910},"Brendan Donovan","brendan-donovan",{"_38":912,"_34":906,"_36":913},"JJ Wetherholt","jj-wetherholt",{"_38":915,"_34":906,"_36":916},"Oli Marmol","oli-marmol","contentLength",110,"defaultImage","pageViews","commentCount","0","categoryFilter",{"_925":926,"_927":928},"property","specs.tag","values",[929],"stl-sports-central","slugUrl","2025/06/13/the-bernie-show-6-13-25","lock",{"_934":53,"_935":-5,"_936":-5,"_937":-5},"isLocked","userName","userId","date","categoryId","userReactions",[],"reactionSummary",[],"feedPageHeading","feedPageHeadingLineTwo","feedPageTitle","feedPageDescription","prohibitComments","prohibitReactions","hideFeaturedImage","advancedOptions","feedBorderOverrideColor","feedBlurb","tag",[955,957,959,961,963,965,967,968,969,970,971,972,973],{"_7":953,"_753":956},"sports",{"_7":953,"_753":958},"missouri-sports",{"_7":953,"_753":960},"saint-louis-sports",{"_7":953,"_753":962},"saint-louis",{"_7":953,"_753":964},"st-louis",{"_7":953,"_753":966},"st-louis-sports",{"_7":953,"_753":929},{"_7":898,"_753":899},{"_7":902,"_753":903},{"_7":906,"_753":907},{"_7":906,"_753":910},{"_7":906,"_753":913},{"_7":906,"_753":916},"isPremium","isWarning","isTertiary","hasEmbed","types",[980],"video","videoInfo",{"_983":984},"url","https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WIa0GrLn4E0","podcastInfo",{"_983":18},"relatedArticles",{"_15":989,"_990":991},[],"filters",[992],{"_925":926,"_927":993},[929],"thumbnail","/img/random/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-6-13-25-thumbnail.jpg","publishedOn","2025-06-13T17:45:00.000Z","featuredImageUrl","cacheKey","shstl_the-bernie-show-6-13-25","cachedOn","2026-04-16T01:35:03.814Z","contentBlocks",[1005,1011,1014,1016,1018],{"_34":1006,"_15":1007,"_1010":18},"ad",{"_34":82,"_36":128,"_38":128,"_39":18,"_41":18,"_42":23,"_43":129,"_44":18,"_46":18,"_47":18,"_48":18,"_50":1008,"_52":53,"_54":53,"_55":53,"_56":53,"_57":1009},[],{"_59":18,"_60":18,"_61":18,"_62":18,"_63":18,"_64":18,"_65":18,"_66":18,"_68":18,"_69":18},"html",{"_34":1012,"_1010":1013},"text","

",{"_34":1012,"_1010":1015},"

",{"_34":1012,"_1010":1017},"

",{"_34":1012,"_1010":1017},"metaSettings",{"_370":371,"_372":373,"_147":374,"_375":371,"_376":377,"_378":377,"_379":377,"_380":377,"_381":1021,"_390":391,"_392":18,"_393":377,"_394":377,"_395":377,"_396":397},{"_383":384,"_385":386,"_387":388,"_389":329},"sidebarSections",[1024,1119],{"_162":1025,"_1028":1029,"_1030":1031,"_1032":1031,"_990":1033},{"_370":1026,"_372":18,"_1027":18},"Bernie Miklasz Written Content","image","articles",[],"desktopLayoutStyle","default","mobileLayoutStyle",[1034],{"_34":953,"_36":1035,"_1036":217,"_15":1037,"_1050":1051,"_927":1052,"_1117":45,"_978":1118},"bernie-miklasz","count",{"_36":1035,"_38":1038,"_879":-5,"_34":953,"_140":1039,"_1048":1049},"bernie miklasz",{"_142":1040,"_143":1041,"_147":-5,"_148":1043,"_150":-5,"_151":-5,"_152":1044},"973aec08-a44b-4277-b40c-693f768934cd",{"_36":-5,"_7":1042,"_146":-5},"Specification",[],{"_154":1045,"_156":1046,"_158":1046,"_159":1047},"2025-03-23T14:57:49.169Z","9c11c01e-d312-4b5a-a115-bf834a35f1e0","2025-03-23T14:57:49.171Z","contentTypes",[865],"load","preload",[1053,1075,1089,1103],{"_1027":1054,"_867":1055,"_930":1056,"_953":1038,"_937":1057,"_996":1058,"_875":1059,"_881":1062,"_370":1063,"_392":1064,"_892":1064,"_974":53,"_975":53,"_976":53,"_1065":190,"_921":922,"_36":1066,"_442":865,"_1067":53,"_939":1068,"_941":1069,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1070":53,"_950":1071,"_869":1066,"_981":1072,"_1073":18,"_1074":-5,"_952":-5},"/img/bernie/bernie-central-rev-544x306.jpg","bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-4-15-26","/2026/04/15/bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-4-15-26","2026-04-15T23:20:14.289Z","2026-04-15T23:36:00.000Z",{"_38":332,"_36":1060,"_879":1061},"berniemiklasz","/avatars/berniemiklasz.jpg",[],"REDBIRD REVIEW: The Defiant, Determined Cardinals Refuse to Go Away","The Cardinals are 5-0 in one-run games and have won eight of nine contests determined by no more than a two-run margin.","viewCount","e76b1752-410b-435c-a24a-77ee2a12689b","isLiveFile",[],[],"prohibitReactionsInComments",{},{"_983":-5},"externalUrl","subHeadings",{"_1027":1054,"_867":1076,"_930":1077,"_953":1038,"_937":1078,"_996":1079,"_875":1080,"_881":1081,"_370":1082,"_392":1083,"_892":1083,"_974":53,"_975":53,"_976":53,"_1065":190,"_921":190,"_36":1084,"_442":865,"_1067":53,"_939":1085,"_941":1086,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1070":53,"_950":1087,"_869":1084,"_981":1088,"_1073":18,"_1074":-5,"_952":-5},"bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-4-14-26","/2026/04/14/bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-4-14-26","2026-04-14T22:18:41.205Z","2026-04-14T22:28:04.873Z",{"_38":332,"_36":1060,"_879":1061},[],"REDBIRD REVIEW: Jordan Walker is Thriving in a Mess","The Cardinals have lost three consecutive games to level off to 8-8 on the season. The Guardians and the Red Sox came to town to remind the locals that the rebuilding can be frustrating. This isn’t like that upbeat and snappy PBS show, “This Old House.” ","bdec46ac-f81c-4ff6-aa96-9374ee0506d4",[],[],{},{"_983":-5},{"_1027":1054,"_867":1090,"_930":1091,"_953":1038,"_937":1092,"_996":1093,"_875":1094,"_881":1095,"_370":1096,"_392":1097,"_892":1097,"_974":53,"_975":53,"_976":53,"_1065":190,"_921":922,"_36":1098,"_442":865,"_1067":53,"_939":1099,"_941":1100,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1070":53,"_950":1101,"_869":1098,"_981":1102,"_1073":18,"_1074":-5,"_952":-5},"bernie-miklasz-redbird-bonus-4-21-25","/2026/04/13/bernie-miklasz-redbird-bonus-4-21-25","2026-04-13T22:03:36.223Z","2026-04-13T22:14:00.000Z",{"_38":332,"_36":1060,"_879":1061},[],"Bernie Bonus: The Daily J Walker","In the past eight games, Jordan Walker splattered six pitches for home runs, batted .406, and got on base in 46 percent of his plate appearances.","009e5e8c-0168-4783-b1a7-2628b312cef0",[],[],{},{"_983":-5},{"_1027":1054,"_867":1104,"_930":1105,"_953":1038,"_937":1106,"_996":1107,"_875":1108,"_881":1109,"_370":1110,"_392":1111,"_892":1111,"_974":53,"_975":53,"_976":53,"_1065":190,"_921":922,"_36":1112,"_442":865,"_1067":53,"_939":1113,"_941":1114,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1070":53,"_950":1115,"_869":1112,"_981":1116,"_1073":18,"_1074":-5,"_952":-5},"bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-4-13-26","/2026/04/13/bernie-miklasz-redbird-review-4-13-26","2026-04-13T20:17:45.275Z","2026-04-13T20:42:00.000Z",{"_38":332,"_36":1060,"_879":1061},[],"REDBIRD REVIEW: Cards Shortage of Strikeout Punch Is a Problem","Ten of the 15 pitchers used by the Cardinals this season have strikeout rates below 15 percent.","4fd718d6-d730-4121-ba8c-a059d2893076",[],[],{},{"_983":-5},"skip",[865],{"_162":1120,"_1028":1121,"_1030":1031,"_1032":1031,"_990":1122},{"_370":901,"_372":18,"_1027":18},[],[1123],{"_34":902,"_36":903,"_1117":190,"_1036":217,"_15":1124,"_1050":1051,"_927":1134,"_978":1204},{"_879":-5,"_34":902,"_36":903,"_38":901,"_1125":53,"_140":1126,"_1048":1133},"isHidden",{"_142":1127,"_143":1128,"_147":-5,"_148":1129,"_150":-5,"_151":-5,"_152":1130},"4c4a795a-2dd7-46d4-926b-9a1a3c87ac55",{"_36":-5,"_7":1042,"_146":-5},[],{"_154":1131,"_156":157,"_158":157,"_159":1132},"2025-01-24T15:00:01.364Z","2025-01-24T15:00:02.715Z",[865],[1135,1155,1170,1187],{"_1027":1136,"_867":1137,"_930":1138,"_953":901,"_937":1139,"_996":1140,"_1141":1142,"_875":1143,"_881":1147,"_370":1148,"_392":1149,"_892":1149,"_974":53,"_975":53,"_976":53,"_1065":190,"_921":922,"_36":1150,"_442":865,"_1067":53,"_939":1151,"_941":1152,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1070":53,"_950":1153,"_869":1150,"_981":1154,"_1073":18,"_1074":-5,"_952":-5},"/img/cardinals/usatsi_28730778_168416177_lowres-544x306.jpg","wetherholt-herrera-surge-cardinals","/2026/04/15/wetherholt-herrera-surge-cardinals","2026-04-15T17:26:39.223Z","2026-04-15T17:59:17.429Z","photoCredit","Jeff Curry-Imagn Images",{"_38":1144,"_36":1145,"_879":1146},"Brenden Schaeffer","brendenschaeffer","/avatars/brendenschaeffer.jpg",[],"For Cardinals, Tuesday's surge from Wetherholt and Herrera was only a matter of time","If you had only glanced at the season-long numbers for the top two hitters in the Cardinals lineup prior to Tuesday night’s win over the Guardians, you might have had some real concerns about both JJ Wetherholt and Ivan Herrera.","7f8c64e6-304e-401a-9c92-f151fe623035",[],[],{},{"_983":-5},{"_1027":1156,"_867":1157,"_930":1158,"_953":371,"_937":1159,"_996":1160,"_875":1161,"_881":1162,"_370":1163,"_392":1164,"_892":1164,"_974":53,"_975":53,"_976":53,"_1065":190,"_921":922,"_36":1165,"_442":865,"_1067":53,"_939":1166,"_941":1167,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1070":53,"_950":1168,"_869":1165,"_981":1169,"_1073":18,"_1074":-5,"_952":-5},"/img/cardinals/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-4-14-26-544x306.jpg","the-bernie-show-4-14-26","/2026/04/14/the-bernie-show-4-14-26","2026-04-14T18:37:12.799Z","2026-04-14T18:40:00.000Z",{"_38":877,"_36":878,"_879":880},[],"The Bernie Show: Do Chicks Still Dig the Long Ball?","Bernie Miklasz examines whether Jordan Walker's explosive start to the 2026 season can single-handedly revive Cardinals attendance.","389ae8ce-e6c6-4f4a-854e-b1d4ba8a3348",[],[],{},{"_983":-5},{"_1027":1171,"_867":1172,"_930":1173,"_953":371,"_937":1174,"_996":1175,"_875":1176,"_881":1177,"_370":1178,"_392":1179,"_892":1179,"_974":53,"_975":53,"_976":53,"_1065":190,"_921":922,"_978":1180,"_36":1181,"_442":865,"_1067":53,"_939":1182,"_941":1183,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1070":53,"_950":1184,"_869":1181,"_981":1185,"_1073":18,"_1074":-5,"_952":-5},"/img/cardinals/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-4-13-26-v2-544x306.jpg","the-bernie-show-4-13-26","/2026/04/13/the-bernie-show-4-13-26","2026-04-13T17:36:31.810Z","2026-04-13T17:39:00.000Z",{"_38":877,"_36":878,"_879":880},[],"The Bernie Show: One Man Gang","The 2026 Cardinals have a winning record, but one devastating number reveals they might be the most fragile team in baseball. ",[980],"9361803d-1b07-4bb4-9273-e7ac5b2989b5",[],[],{},{"_983":1186},"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nJDzXlL18-Q",{"_1027":1188,"_867":1189,"_930":1190,"_953":371,"_937":1191,"_996":1192,"_875":1193,"_881":1194,"_370":1195,"_392":1196,"_892":1196,"_974":53,"_975":53,"_976":53,"_1065":190,"_921":922,"_978":1197,"_36":1198,"_442":865,"_1067":53,"_939":1199,"_941":1200,"_947":53,"_948":53,"_1070":53,"_950":1201,"_869":1198,"_981":1202,"_1073":18,"_1074":-5,"_952":-5},"/img/cardinals/bernie-cardinals-thumbnail-4-10-26-544x306.jpg","the-bernie-show-4-10-26","/2026/04/10/the-bernie-show-4-10-26","2026-04-10T18:26:21.283Z","2026-04-10T18:29:00.000Z",{"_38":877,"_36":878,"_879":880},[],"The Bernie Show: Bloom Bringing Good Vibes","Bernie Miklasz breaks down how Chaim Bloom's arrival has reshaped the Cardinals organization from top to bottom as the Red Sox visit Busch Stadium this weekend.",[980],"98514fba-588c-403f-bc77-f83de6f88fe6",[],[],{},{"_983":1203},"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ISKDXpg-4oE",[865],"playerData","actionData","errors"]

The Bernie Show: New Table Setter

REDBIRD REVIEW: The Defiant, Determined Cardinals Refuse to Go Away

By Bernie Miklasz

Apr 15, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Jordan Walker is Thriving in a Mess

By Bernie Miklasz

Apr 14, 2026

Bernie Bonus: The Daily J Walker

By Bernie Miklasz

Apr 13, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Cards Shortage of Strikeout Punch Is a Problem

By Bernie Miklasz

Apr 13, 2026

For Cardinals, Tuesday's surge from Wetherholt and Herrera was only a matter of time

By Brenden Schaeffer

Apr 15, 2026

The Bernie Show: Do Chicks Still Dig the Long Ball?

By HUB STAFF

Apr 14, 2026

The Bernie Show: One Man Gang

By HUB STAFF

Apr 13, 2026

The Bernie Show: Bloom Bringing Good Vibes

By HUB STAFF

Apr 10, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: The Defiant, Determined Cardinals Refuse to Go Away

By Bernie Miklasz

Apr 15, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Jordan Walker is Thriving in a Mess

By Bernie Miklasz

Apr 14, 2026

Bernie Bonus: The Daily J Walker

By Bernie Miklasz

Apr 13, 2026

REDBIRD REVIEW: Cards Shortage of Strikeout Punch Is a Problem

By Bernie Miklasz

Apr 13, 2026

For Cardinals, Tuesday's surge from Wetherholt and Herrera was only a matter of time

By Brenden Schaeffer

Apr 15, 2026

The Bernie Show: Do Chicks Still Dig the Long Ball?

By HUB STAFF

Apr 14, 2026

The Bernie Show: One Man Gang

By HUB STAFF

Apr 13, 2026

The Bernie Show: Bloom Bringing Good Vibes

By HUB STAFF

Apr 10, 2026